Compare Paper Shredders
- 4,461
- 17
- Customize
- All Rankings
Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder vs Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder
Pros: The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder is...
- The Best forPaper Shredders for Everyone
- The Best forSpeedy Paper Shredders
- The Best forBest Paper Shredders
- The Best out of the 379Paper Shredders for Level 3 Security and up
- The Best out of the 227Paper Shredders That Shred Staples
- The Best out of the 175Paper Shredders With Overload Protection
- The Best out of the 103Paper Shredders With Automatic Start/stop
- The Best out of the 65Paper Shredders for Credit Cards
- The Best out of the 65Paper Shredders That Shred Credit Cards
- The Best out of the 51Paper Shredders With Automatic Reverse
Cons: The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder is...
- Bottom Two if you prioritizePaper Shredders With a High Cool Down Time
The Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder is...
- Top Five forSpeedy Paper Shredders
- Top 2% forPaper Shredders for a Low Recommended Number of Users
- Top 2% forPaper Shredders for Everyone
- Top 2% forBest Paper Shredders
- Top 2% out of the 379Paper Shredders for Level 3 Security and up
- Top 3% if you're looking forPaper Shredders That Can Handle Staples and Paper Clips
- Top 4% for people looking forPaper Shredders for High Volume Use
- Top 4% for those who wantPaper Shredders for Throat Width
- Top 4% out of the 227Paper Shredders That Shred Staples
- Top 4% for those who wantCompact Paper Shredders
The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder is ranked highest among the best paper shredders out of those selected. First of all, each of these two paper shredders is intended for home & home office use, so they're not differentiable in that regard. Based on input from our users, other than intended use the most important dimensions of evaluation to consider if you're looking for the best paper shredders are, in order of importance: (1) price, (2) performance, (3) noise level, (4) size and (5) convenience. (It should be mentioned that model information is also important in choosing the best paper shredders, but it isn't the kind of factor on which paper shredders can be directly compared.) In addition to being the overall winner, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder is also the best in this group for performance and noise level. However, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder scores best in price and size. These two paper shredders score equally well for convenience. (more)
Best Paper Shredders
Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder
- Price: $204
- Intended Use: Home & home office
Staples Minimate 6-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder (White)
- Price: $49.99
- Intended Use: Home & home office
Swingline E10-06 10-Sheet Extended Run Time Cross-Cut Shredder
- Price: $249.99
- Intended Use: Home & home office
Staples Minimate 6-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder (Black)
- Price: $49.99
- Intended Use: Home & home office
Fellowes Powershred P-45C 6-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder
- Price: $76.64
- Intended Use: Home & home office
| 79186 | 79195 |
|---|
Most Important Facts for Best Paper Shredders:
Top Fact Comparison
| Mark Better Values | Swingline Stack And Shredde... | Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs ... | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for price, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. $204 (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for price, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. $99.99 (wrong info?) |
Similar Paper Shredders
Similar Paper Shredders
|
| Intended Use |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders have selected home & home office as the top choice for intended use, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance in this category. Home & home office (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders have selected home & home office as the top choice for intended use, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance in this category. Home & home office (wrong info?) |
|
|
Decibel Level
Decibel Level
The level of noise a shredder makes while in use is measured in decibels (dB). Current shredders tend to operate in the 60-80 dB range. 60 dB roughly corresponds to the noise level of a nearby conversation, while 80 dB might be the noise level of a busy street.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for decibel level, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. 60 decibels (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for decibel level, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. 72 decibels (wrong info?) |
|
|
Continuous Run Time
Continuous Run Time
Shredder motors will overheat and burn out if used continuously for too long. This is the recommended maximum amount of time that the shredder should run before being allowed to cool down.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for continuous run time, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 41% performance in this category. 20 minutes (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for continuous run time, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 23% performance in this category. 12 minutes (wrong info?) |
|
|
Cool Down Time
Cool Down Time
Indicates the recommended amount of time that a shredder be allowed to cool off between uses.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for cool down time, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance in this category. 10 minutes (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for cool down time, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 87% performance in this category. 20 minutes (wrong info?) |
|
|
Performs Best In
Performs Best In:
Who are these Paper Shredders best for?
These facts tell you where they score the highest and who they
are likely to perform best for.
|
|||
|
Compare Prices
Support Pikimal!
Ready to make a decision and purchase an Paper Shredder? Using these links will support Pikimal while making your purchase.
|
Find on Amazon | Find on Amazon |
Comparing the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder to the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder: Which is the best paper shredder?
Price
The Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder costs $99.99, so it is inexpensive relative to all of the other paper shredders in our database. Moreover, between the paper shredders currently being compared, it has the best score for price, given that people looking for the best paper shredders prefer lower values for price. The Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder costs $99.99 and the average price for paper shredders is $1,728.
| Mark Better Values | Swingline Stack And Shredde... | Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs ... | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for price, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. $204 (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for price, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. $99.99 (wrong info?) |
Performance
The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder scores best for performance between these two paper shredders. Here's how it does on some key aspects of performance:
- Each of these paper shredders, including the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder, can shred credit cards.
- Each of these paper shredders can shred CDs and DVDs.
- Both of these paper shredders are able to shred staples.
- Each of these paper shredders can shred paper clips.
- It shreds up to 7 pages per minute. Compare the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder at 12 pages per minute.
| Mark Better Values | Swingline Stack And Shredde... | Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs ... | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Composite Score |
The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 69% performance for composite score. However, the current preferences ignore composite score in computing the rankings. 65 out of 100 (wrong info?) |
The Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 78% performance for composite score. However, the current preferences ignore composite score in computing the rankings. 74 out of 100 (wrong info?) |
Similar Performance
Similar Performance
|
|
Sheet Shred Capacity
Sheet Shred Capacity
Sheet capacity is the number of sheets of paper a shredder can handle at one time.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for sheet shred capacity, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 2% performance in this category. 16 sheets per pass (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for sheet shred capacity, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 1% performance in this category. 13 sheets per pass (wrong info?) |
|
| Recommended Number of Users |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for recommended number of users, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 0% performance in this category. 5 users (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for recommended number of users, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 0% performance in this category. 1 user (wrong info?) |
|
|
Cool Down Time
Cool Down Time
Indicates the recommended amount of time that a shredder be allowed to cool off between uses.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for cool down time, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance in this category. 10 minutes (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for cool down time, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 87% performance in this category. 20 minutes (wrong info?) |
|
|
Continuous Run Time
Continuous Run Time
Shredder motors will overheat and burn out if used continuously for too long. This is the recommended maximum amount of time that the shredder should run before being allowed to cool down.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for continuous run time, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 41% performance in this category. 20 minutes (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for continuous run time, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 23% performance in this category. 12 minutes (wrong info?) |
|
| Durability Rating |
|
|
|
| Shred Speed Rating |
|
|
|
| Capabilities | |||
| Capabilities |
The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance for capabilities. Shreds staples, shreds paper clips, shreds credit cards, shreds CDs/DVDs (wrong info?) |
The Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance for capabilities. Shreds staples, shreds paper clips, shreds credit cards, shreds CDs/DVDs (wrong info?) |
Similar Capabilities
Similar Capabilities
|
| Shred Speed |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for shred speed, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 2% performance in this category. 7 pages per minute (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for shred speed, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 5% performance in this category. 12 pages per minute (wrong info?) |
|
| Shred Size | |||
|
Shred Size Length
Shred Size Length
Indicates the length of the particles or the width of the strips into which the shredder cuts paper. More secure shredders cut paper into smaller particles.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for shred size length, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. 0.25 inches (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for shred size length, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. 0.15 inches (wrong info?) |
Similar Shred Size
Similar Shred Size
|
|
Shred Size Width
Shred Size Width
Indicates the length of the particles or the width of the strips into which the shredder cuts paper. More secure shredders cut paper into smaller particles.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for shred size width, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 97% performance in this category. 1.75 inches (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for shred size width, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 97% performance in this category. 1.50 inches (wrong info?) |
|
| Ratings | |||
| Shopping.com Rating |
We currently have no data on the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder for Shopping.com rating.
|
We currently have no data on the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder for Shopping.com rating.
|
|
Noise Level
The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder scores best for noise level between these two paper shredders. Here's how it does on some key aspects of noise level:
- It runs quietly. Compare the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder, which does not run quietly.
| Mark Better Values | Swingline Stack And Shredde... | Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs ... | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Noise Level |
The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance for noise level. Quiet operation (wrong info?) |
The Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 0% performance for noise level. No special noise level details (wrong info?) |
Similar Noise Level
Similar Noise Level
|
|
Decibel Level
Decibel Level
The level of noise a shredder makes while in use is measured in decibels (dB). Current shredders tend to operate in the 60-80 dB range. 60 dB roughly corresponds to the noise level of a nearby conversation, while 80 dB might be the noise level of a busy street.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for decibel level, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. 60 decibels (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for decibel level, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 99% performance in this category. 72 decibels (wrong info?) |
Intended Use
| Mark Better Values | Swingline Stack And Shredde... | Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs ... | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Intended Use |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders have selected home & home office as the top choice for intended use, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance in this category. Home & home office (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders have selected home & home office as the top choice for intended use, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance in this category. Home & home office (wrong info?) |
Similar Intended Use
Similar Intended Use
|
Size
The Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder scores best for size between these two paper shredders. Here's how the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder does on some key aspects of size:
- It holds less shredded paper than average (wastebasket capacity: 6 gallons). Compare the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder at 8 gallons.
- It is 12.19 inches wide. Compare the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder at 17 inches.
- It is 15.38 inches deep. Compare the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder at 13 inches.
- It is 21.50 inches tall. Compare the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder at 22 inches.
- Both of these paper shredders have a throat width of 9 inches.
| Mark Better Values | Swingline Stack And Shredde... | Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs ... | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Throat Width
Throat Width
A shredder's throat is where documents are fed in to be shredded. Most are at least wide enough to accommodate letter-size paper (eight and one-half inches). Wider throats can handle larger document sizes.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for throat width, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 42% performance in this category. 9 inches (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for throat width, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 42% performance in this category. 9 inches (wrong info?) |
Similar Size
Similar Size
|
|
Wastebasket Capacity
Wastebasket Capacity
Some shredders have a wastebasket or bag that collects the shredded particles and needs to be emptied when full.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for wastebasket capacity, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 18% performance in this category. 8 gallons (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer higher values for wastebasket capacity, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 13% performance in this category. 6 gallons (wrong info?) |
|
| Height |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for height, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 67% performance in this category. 22 inches (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for height, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 68% performance in this category. 21.50 inches (wrong info?) |
|
| Width |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for width, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 66% performance in this category. 17 inches (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for width, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 77% performance in this category. 12.19 inches (wrong info?) |
|
| Depth |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for depth, the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 91% performance in this category. 13 inches (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall paper shredders prefer lower values for depth, the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 89% performance in this category. 15.38 inches (wrong info?) |
Convenience
The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder and the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder both score equally well for convenience. Here's how they compare on the most important aspects of convenience:
- It has an automatic reverse function. Compare the Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder, which doesn't have an automatic reverse function.
- Both of these paper shredders have level 3 security.
- It uses Safe Sense technology. Compare the Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder, which does not use Safe Sense technology.
- Both of these paper shredders have automatic start/stop.
- Both of these paper shredders have overload protection.
| Mark Better Values | Swingline Stack And Shredde... | Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs ... | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Convenience |
The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 84% performance for convenience. Overload protection, automatic start/stop, automatic reverse (wrong info?) |
The Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 84% performance for convenience. Overload protection, automatic start/stop, Safe Sense technology (wrong info?) |
Similar Convenience
Similar Convenience
|
|
Security Level
Security Level
The security level of a shredder is related to the size of the paper particles it produces. More secure shredders cut paper into smaller pieces. There are six Security Levels. Security Level 3 is commonly recommended as the minimum level for disposal of sensitive personal documents, while Security Level 6 is approved by the United States Department of Defense for diposal of top secret documents.
|
The Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance for security level. Level 3 (wrong info?) |
The Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs 9-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder achieves 100% performance for security level. Level 3 (wrong info?) |
|
| Capacity Rating |
|
|
Model Information
| Mark Better Values | Swingline Stack And Shredde... | Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs ... | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Model Number |
1757571 |
3225901 |
|
| Manufacturer Name |
Gbc (wrong info?) |
Fellowes (wrong info?) |
|
| Manufacturer Website |
Manufacturer Website (wrong info?) |
Manufacturer Website (wrong info?) |
|
| Availability |
currently available (wrong info?) |
currently available (wrong info?) |
|
| UPC |
(wrong info?) |
(wrong info?) |
Where to Buy:
| Mark Better Values | Swingline Stack And Shredde... | Fellowes Powershred P-58Cs ... | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Where to Buy
Where to Buy:
Use these links to purchase, support Pikimal in the process.
|
Find on Amazon | Find on Amazon |
Similar Paper Shredders
Similar Paper Shredders
|
Data Contributors:
Swingline Stack And Shredder Automatic Cross-Cut Shredder Price Comparison
| Sale | Price | Merchant |
|---|